Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Energy

From an earlier edition

Counting the Carbon From Bushfires: Are Wildfires Really Neutral?

A 2020 piece questioning the long-held view that carbon from wildfires is fully reabsorbed by regrowth, and arguing that fire control deserves a place in climate policy.

2020Long readEnergy3 min read

Key points

  • Emissions accounting long treated wildfire carbon as cancelled out by later regrowth.
  • Revised international guidance in 2019 let countries report fire emissions separately.
  • Some research suggested around a tenth of wildfire carbon stays in the air for good.
  • Hotter conditions were making fires bigger and more frequent, which could feed further warming.

Background: why fires were left out

For decades, the carbon dioxide released by wildfires was treated as a temporary loan. The working assumption, built into the emissions rules of the late 1990s, was that vegetation would grow back and soak the carbon up again, so fires were close to neutral over the long run. Australia's national inventory therefore counted only the methane and nitrous oxide from bushfires, a very small slice of total emissions.

In 2019 the international climate science panel updated its reporting guidance. Because fires were becoming more frequent and severe, countries could now publish two sets of figures: one including natural disturbances such as wildfire and one excluding them.

Writing in September 2020, after the severe 2019-20 fire season, the article noted that a federal government assessment had concluded those fires would barely affect Australia's emissions targets, since burnt forests generally recover and then draw down carbon for years. The piece accepted that this might hold for Australia, but argued the picture elsewhere was less reassuring.

What the newer evidence suggested

Two problems stood out. First, even where regrowth eventually captures the carbon, it lingers in the atmosphere for several months beforehand, adding to warming during that time. Second, fires were getting larger, hotter and more costly, particularly in parts of the Americas and Africa, and fire seasons were lengthening. Some research indicated that roughly a tenth of fire carbon is never recaptured, and the article considered that estimate cautious.

The danger is a feedback loop. Heat dries out the landscape, fires burn more often and more intensely, burnt country regrows less vigorously and stores less carbon, and the extra carbon pushes temperatures higher still.

Rough scale

Estimating emissions from any single fire is difficult, because tropical savannah burns quite differently from temperate forest, and a canopy fire that consumes everything differs from a patchy ground fire. Even so, the piece worked through broad figures. Using wide ranges for area burnt and carbon released per hectare, it suggested that in an average year Australian wildfires could emit anything from roughly as much carbon as the nation's industry to several times more, and far more in an extreme year. Globally the ratio was lower, but fires still added a large share on top of industrial output.

The article separated wildfires from planned burning, stubble burning and traditional Aboriginal fire management, and also from deliberate forest clearing for farming, which it treated as a separate and major climate problem.

A less divisive lever

The author observed that cutting fossil fuel use had proved slow and politically bitter, with rich and developing nations at odds. Reducing wildfires, by contrast, had drawn little attention despite its potential. Options mentioned included changing land management in savannah and scrub and restoring the kind of grazing pressure that once kept fuel loads in check. Preventing fires and letting stable vegetation grow would both avoid emissions and lock carbon into plants and soil.

Why it matters for Australia

Bushfire smoke and regrowth sit at the heart of how Australia counts land-sector emissions, so the treatment of fire carbon affected how progress on its targets was measured. Fire management in northern savannah also linked climate goals with regional land care and Indigenous ranger work.

First published in 2020 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions