Key points
- Cutting future emissions alone was unlikely to hold warming to the global target; existing carbon also had to be removed.
- Storing carbon in deep rock formations looked the most promising technical option, though gaps remained.
- Ocean storage offered huge capacity but carried high costs and unknown ecological risks.
- Rebuilding carbon in farm soils could store carbon while making land more productive.
Why drawdown mattered
Since industrialisation began, human activity, chiefly burning wood and fossil fuels, had added more than 2,000 gigatonnes of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere. By 2020 a strong body of scientific opinion held that trimming future emissions would not on its own keep warming within two degrees of pre-industrial levels, the goal set at the Paris climate talks. The carbon already in the air would have to be drawn down, a process often called negative emissions. Drawdown would also offset industries that could not cut their own emissions quickly.
Capturing waste carbon at large sources such as power stations, then moving it to a storage site, was widely seen as part of the answer, and ten countries producing about a third of global emissions had named it in their climate pledges. Both approaches depend on somewhere to keep carbon for a very long time, and the realistic options were limited.
Rock, minerals and the sea
Geological storage means pumping gas into deep formations such as spent oil and gas fields or salty aquifers. It was considered the most promising route because the storage was expected to last, capacity was large and the science was fairly well understood. A large project of this kind was already running off the Western Australian coast. Even so, capability gaps and long lead times remained.
Mineral storage reacts carbon dioxide with common silicate rocks to form stable carbonates, copying natural weathering. Suitable rock is plentiful, but the reaction is slow and speeding it up takes so much energy that a power station using it would need well over half as much energy again. The technology was still at the development stage.
The ocean is the largest carbon store on Earth and had absorbed a large share of human emissions, but its uptake was expected to weaken as seawater chemistry changed, and the extra carbon was already acidifying surface waters. Injecting gas directly into the deep sea might keep it out of the air for centuries but not millennia, had never been proven at scale and posed unknown risks to marine life. Fertilising the sea with iron to boost plankton was another high-risk idea.
Plants and soils
Vegetation already soaked up about a third of fossil fuel emissions, but that uptake would fade as forests matured and nutrients ran short. Replanting and plantations could make a meaningful contribution in the shorter term, with permanence depending on what happened to the timber.
Soils hold several times more carbon than the atmosphere, yet most farmed soils had lost half or more of their original organic carbon through clearing, tillage, grazing, stubble burning and erosion. Reduced tillage, manure and compost, crop rotation, cover crops and perennial plants on steep ground could rebuild it, though gains were capped by soil type and climate, and warming could speed up the release of the more short-lived forms. Biochar, a charcoal made by heating crop waste, wood or manure with little oxygen, could stay in the ground for centuries or longer and showed promise for yields and soil health, though its overall farm benefits were still being studied.
No single fix
Relying on one method seemed both unlikely and unwise. A mix suited to local conditions offered the sturdiest result. High-technology options were still maturing and could prove costly or carry unforeseen effects, while restoring soil carbon offered the double gain of storing carbon and helping feed a growing world.
Why it matters for Australia
With large cropping and grazing regions and a major geological storage project already running off its west coast, Australia had a stake in both soil carbon and underground storage. How these options were valued in national climate policy had direct consequences for farmers and for the resources sector.
First published in 2020 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.
Related from earlier editions
- Counting the Carbon From Bushfires: Are Wildfires Really Neutral?2020 | Energy
- Drier Years Ahead: The Risk to Turkey's Dams and Hydroelectric Plans2019 | Energy
- Counting Carbon in the Ground: Why Soil Is Hard to Measure2018 | Energy
- Indonesia's climate pledges and the pull of poverty reduction2018 | Energy
More from earlier editions
- Earlier analysis sorted by topic Regions