Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Energy

From an earlier edition

Indonesia's climate pledges and the pull of poverty reduction

How Indonesia, a major but often overlooked emitter, tried in 2018 to square its climate commitments with growth, coal power, biofuels and the fight against poverty.

2018Long readEnergy4 min read

Key points

  • Most Indonesian emissions came from land clearing and peat and forest fires rather than burning fossil fuels.
  • Jakarta pledged to cut emissions well below business as usual by 2030, with a deeper cut if foreign funding arrived.
  • A moratorium on clearing primary forest and peat, plus a wetter year, helped slow tree cover loss.
  • Plans for new coal plants and more palm-based biofuel made the 2030 targets look hard to reach.

Background

Indonesia ranked among the world's largest greenhouse gas emitters in 2018, yet it drew far less attention than other big polluters. Its profile was unusual: most emissions came from land use change, deforestation and peat and forest fires, with fossil fuels responsible for only about a fifth. As the population grew wealthier, that mix was expected to shift, and energy was projected to become the largest source within a decade.

Climate policy rose up the agenda late in the previous president's second term. In 2009 he promised a cut of roughly a quarter against projected emissions by 2020, rising further with international help. Those promises fed into the national climate plan submitted ahead of the 2015 climate conference in Paris. After parliament ratified the resulting agreement in 2016, Indonesia pledged a 29 per cent cut below business as usual by 2030, rising to 41 per cent if wealthy countries provided substantial funding.

Balancing growth and emissions

The government saw the country as highly exposed to a warming climate. A low-lying archipelago with many small islands faces rising seas and more extreme weather, and climate change threatens farming and therefore food and water security. At the same time, around a tenth of the population still lived below the poverty line. Jakarta aimed to keep growth at a solid pace and bring poverty below four per cent by 2025, and it feared that aggressive climate measures could slow that effort.

Forests and peat

Because Indonesia was the world's leading source of forest-based emissions, land policy carried the most weight. From 2010 a moratorium barred new permits to develop primary forest and peatland across a vast area, backed by a large pledge of results-based funding from Norway. It was extended in 2015 and again in 2017. In 2017, while tropical tree loss worldwide was among the worst on record, Indonesia's loss fell sharply, helped by a ban on draining peat and by wetter weather that meant fewer fires. Modelling suggested that extending the moratorium to secondary forest and closing exemptions would be the single most effective step.

After the record peat fires of 2015 the government set up a dedicated agency to restore burnt peatland, but high costs and thin funding held it back. Officials also acknowledged that concerns about transparency were limiting foreign support, and planned a new body to channel and audit conservation funds.

Energy and biofuels

Energy policy pulled in the other direction. A national target sought a much larger renewable share of primary energy by 2025, yet the updated 2018 plan proposed far more new coal capacity than renewables over the coming decade, continuing a trend in which coal had vastly outpaced clean power since 2013. Generous incentives were also set to double biofuel demand, which would mean expanding palm oil plantations and likely more clearing. Biofuel plantations and smallholders, who held a large share of oil palm land, were exempt from the national sustainability certification. Making it compulsory for smallholders could help track emissions but might burden farmers who lacked formal land titles.

What to watch

Climate change was a minor theme ahead of the 2019 presidential election, which pitted the incumbent against his 2014 rival; both had offered only vague pledges to rehabilitate degraded land. Jakarta remained wary of any policy seen to hurt the poor. Progress on forests was real, but meeting the 2030 targets would require serious action on energy emissions.

Why it matters for Australia

Indonesia's peat fires, forest losses and coal expansion affect regional air quality, emissions and climate diplomacy right on Australia's doorstep. Its growing appetite for coal also bore on Australian energy exports and on the credibility of shared regional climate commitments.

First published in 2018 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions