Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Energy

From an earlier edition

Counting Carbon in the Ground: Why Soil Is Hard to Measure

A guide to the forms carbon takes in farm soils, the laboratory tests used to measure it, and why tracking change across rangelands remained so difficult.

2018Long readEnergy3 min read

Key points

  • Soil holds carbon in organic, charcoal and mineral forms, each behaving differently.
  • Careful field sampling followed by high-temperature laboratory combustion remained the most reliable test.
  • Depth and seasonal swings made measuring change far harder than measuring a single value.
  • Satellite and drone methods looked promising but still needed laboratory baselines, especially for northern rangelands.

Background

Carbon is one of the most common elements on Earth and the backbone of every living thing, able to build large and varied molecules at everyday temperatures. Soils store enormous amounts of it, and that store is always moving between air, plants, soil and sea. Photosynthesis pulls carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere, and some of it can end up locked in the ground for long periods. With carbon trading, offsets and credits emerging as part of the response to climate change, knowing how much carbon a paddock holds, and whether that amount is rising, took on real economic value.

Three forms of soil carbon

For measurement purposes, soil carbon falls into three broad groups.

  • Organic matter comes from roots, leaves, microbes, fungi and animals. It holds water, binds soil into crumbs that resist erosion and is the usual yardstick of a healthy soil. It is also the least stable form, readily broken down by bacteria, but the easiest to build through plant growth, perennial grasses, manure and compost.
  • Charcoal, often called biochar, is organic in origin but far more resistant to decay, which is why adding it to soil drew interest as a way to store carbon.
  • Inorganic carbon, mainly carbonates, is common in dry and alkaline soils. It is stable and a large store overall, though it changes slowly and does little for fertility.

How it is measured

There is no single correct method; the right choice depends on why the measurement is being made. Building soil health needs less precision than earning carbon credits. Soil carbon also cannot be measured directly, so every method carries some assumptions.

The most reliable approach at the time was repeated, careful sampling in the field, followed by dry combustion in a laboratory. A small ground sample is heated to around 900 degrees and the carbon dioxide released is measured, giving total carbon. Where carbonates are present, an acid wash removes them first so organic and mineral carbon can be separated. Older tests based on weight loss after heating, or on chemical oxidation, were cheaper but less complete, often missing charcoal and mineral carbon. Laboratories also split organic carbon into fractions, from fresh crop residue through to long-lived humus and stable charcoal, while soil respiration and bulk density tests gave useful but indirect clues.

The rangeland problem

Single readings were achievable on cropping land, if slow and costly. Measuring change was harder. Carbon content shifts with the seasons and extends a metre or more below the surface, and both complicate any comparison over time. Researchers were working on satellite and drone methods that read light reflected from plants and bare soil and then estimate carbon with complex models. Those tools still needed laboratory baselines and could not yet handle depth or seasonal variation.

At the time of writing there was no affordable, accurate way to measure carbon across the vast pastoral rangelands of northern Australia. Graziers and researchers saw such a tool as a precondition for a rangeland soil method under the national carbon farming scheme.

Why it still matters

Beyond carbon markets, a century of farming had run down soil carbon in many districts, and rebuilding it promised better yields and more resilient land alongside any climate benefit.

Why it matters for Australia

Northern Australia's grazing lands cover a huge area, so a reliable way to measure soil carbon there could open carbon income to pastoralists. Better soil carbon also underpins farm productivity, making the measurement problem relevant to Australia's agricultural plans whatever happens to carbon prices.

First published in 2018 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions