Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

Idlib 2020: How Syria Strained the Ties Between Moscow and Ankara

A look at the deadly February 2020 strike on Turkish troops in north-west Syria and why it left Russia and Turkey wary partners rather than friends.

2020Long readIndian Ocean3 min read

Key points

  • Russia and Turkey backed opposite sides in Syria's civil war, each for its own strategic reasons.
  • An air strike in Idlib killed more than 30 Turkish soldiers, Turkey's worst single loss in Syria.
  • Neither country could afford a direct war with the other, so both looked for a new arrangement.
  • Trust between the two leaderships was badly damaged and was likely to take years to rebuild.

What happened

Late in February 2020 an air strike in Syria's Idlib province killed 33 Turkish soldiers and wounded dozens more. Ankara said Syrian and Russian aircraft were both involved and that it had told Russian officers where its troops were. Moscow blamed Syrian forces and claimed the Turkish units had been operating alongside rebel groups. Turkey answered by striking a large number of Syrian government targets.

The episode exposed how empty a 2018 understanding between the two countries to keep the peace in Idlib had become. Civilian deaths in the zone had continued, and about a million displaced Syrians had moved towards the Turkish border, adding to the millions of refugees Turkey already hosted.

Why each side was there

Russia backed the Syrian government because its ports on the Syrian coast give the Russian navy a foothold in the eastern Mediterranean and a way out of the Black Sea. A role in the Middle East also served Moscow's aim of being seen as a great power and a counterweight to the United States, building on ties formed in the Cold War. It also wanted to stop militants from returning to Muslim-majority regions of Russia. Iranian forces fought on the same side for their own regional reasons.

Turkey had wanted the Syrian ruler gone since 2011. It blamed him for the war and the refugee flows, and it feared that Kurdish groups were using the conflict to build a self-governing territory along its southern border, which might encourage separatism among Turkey's own Kurds. A government takeover of Idlib would send more refugees north and weaken Turkey's hold on its buffer zones, its bargaining power and its regional standing.

Rising tension

Once government forces captured key towns and road links in the province, Ankara stopped relying on Moscow to restrain them and poured in reinforcements. It also put pressure on Europe by letting refugees head for the Greek border, and asked Western capitals for air defence support, even though it had earlier bought a Russian missile defence system instead of an American one. Turkey's leader and Russia's president then met in Moscow and agreed a new security corridor in Idlib.

Why open war was unlikely

Neither side could afford a direct clash.

  • Turkey's forces were weaker than Russia's, and it could not count on help from its Western military allies after years of strained relations with them.
  • Russia would struggle to supply a fight so far from home, and attacking Turkey risked drawing in those allies and losing its European energy customers.
  • The two were also tied together by a gas pipeline to southern Europe and the Russian arms deal.

Even so, both leaders had built strongman images and could not be seen to back down. Some form of deal over Idlib was likely, but the relatively friendly relationship of earlier years appeared to be over.

Why it matters for Australia

Syria's war shaped refugee flows and great-power rivalry across the Middle East, a region that matters to Australia's security partnerships and to the stability of trade routes linking it to Europe. It also showed how quickly arrangements between strong powers can fray.

First published in 2020 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions