Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

A New Administration in Washington and What It Meant for Pakistan

How Pakistan and the United States approached each other after the change of US president in early 2021, with Afghanistan, China, terror financing and India shaping the agenda.

2021Long readIndian Ocean3 min read

Key points

  • Afghanistan, action against militant groups and Pakistan's closeness to China were set to drive relations.
  • Warm personal ties with the previous US president had not stopped a steep fall in American aid.
  • Islamabad hoped the new president, who had helped design a large civilian aid package years earlier, would restore assistance.
  • With the army steering Pakistan's foreign policy, Washington was likely to keep dealing mainly with the generals.

Background

The new US president who took office in January 2021 was no stranger to Pakistan. As a senator he had been one of the authors of a 2009 law that offered Pakistan about US$7.5 billion in civilian aid over five years to strengthen governance, and as vice-president he had dealt with leaders of both of Pakistan's older parties. Relations had since soured. The previous administration had frozen around US$2 billion in military aid, accusing Islamabad of failing to act against militant networks operating from its soil.

Pakistan's prime minister had enjoyed a friendly rapport with the outgoing US president, even predicting his re-election. After the result, Islamabad moved quickly to court the new team, stressing shared security challenges and offering cooperation on trade, climate and regional peace. The mood was soon tested when Pakistan's highest court acquitted men convicted over the murder of an American journalist, a decision that drew sharp criticism from the new administration.

Afghanistan and China

Afghanistan was expected to dominate. The new administration signalled it would review the deal its predecessor had struck with the Afghan insurgents, arguing they had not reduced violence, negotiated in good faith or cut ties with international terror networks. Pakistan urged Washington to honour the agreement, but a quick drawdown of US troops looked less certain. That gave Islamabad leverage, since the United States still needed its help.

On China, little change was expected. The previous administration had attacked Chinese lending as predatory and singled out the large Chinese-funded infrastructure programme in Pakistan as an example of debt-driven influence, complaining about opaque terms and guaranteed returns for Chinese firms. Pakistan's foreign minister replied that the United States should not treat his country's ties with Beijing as a zero-sum contest. The new team shared many of the same concerns but was likely to accept that Pakistan depended on China economically.

Terror financing and India

Pakistan remained under scrutiny from the global watchdog on money laundering and terror financing, with China shielding it from the worst penalty. Washington faced pressure to take a tougher line, yet its interests in Afghanistan could buy Pakistan some leniency, especially as the army, not the elected government, effectively ran foreign policy.

Islamabad was also expected to press human rights concerns in Kashmir and over Indian citizenship policy, issues on which some American lawmakers had spoken out. But Washington had spent two decades separating its India policy from its Pakistan policy, drawing closer to New Delhi as China rose. Pakistan's own record on minorities, dissent and the army's conduct weakened its case. Earlier hopes of regional trade and pipeline links between India, Pakistan and Afghanistan looked remote, though Pakistan's army chief did call publicly for calmer relations in the region, widely read as a message to the new US team.

What to watch

Experienced Pakistani diplomats were uneasy about growing reliance on Beijing and about strained ties with Gulf states that had bailed Pakistan out before, and they favoured a workable relationship with Washington. The prime minister relied heavily on the military establishment, so the US was expected to deal mostly with the army, perhaps using economic aid to rebuild ties and bolster civilian institutions. Pakistan's tilt towards China remained the biggest obstacle.

Why it matters for Australia

Pakistan's relations with Washington, Beijing and New Delhi shaped security across South Asia and the northern Indian Ocean, a region central to Australia's strategic outlook. How the Western military presence in Afghanistan was wound down also bore on Australia as a close US ally.

First published in 2021 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions