Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

Pakistan in 2020: An Exiled Ex-Leader Takes On the Army and Government

How a three-time former prime minister's attacks on Pakistan's army and its sitting government in late 2020 rallied the opposition and drew a sharp response.

2020Long readIndian Ocean3 min read

Key points

  • A former prime minister, abroad for medical care, accused the army of engineering his removal and the 2018 result.
  • The sitting prime minister and the army rejected the claims and hinted he was serving India's interests.
  • Eleven opposition parties formed a joint front and held large rallies, though some members preferred talks with the army.
  • Retaliation against the former leader and his allies, through arrests and legal cases, was widely expected.

Background

In September and October 2020, Pakistan's three-time former prime minister launched his fiercest attack yet on the country's military and on the sitting prime minister. He spoke first by video to a conference of opposition parties and then at a large rally in Punjab. He had been in the United Kingdom since late 2019 for medical treatment, after being convicted in corruption cases and released on bail, and had not returned when the courts required.

He claimed that the army had worked to topple him, first through street protests led by his rival in 2014 and then through the court cases that removed him from office in 2017. He also recalled being ousted in a military coup in 1999. This time he went further than before, describing the army as a state above the state and arguing that no elected government had been allowed to finish its term while military rulers had faced little accountability. He called the sitting prime minister an army appointee and said the 2018 election had been rigged.

The response

The reaction was swift. A sedition complaint was filed against him by someone close to the ruling party. His brother, a former chief minister of Punjab, was arrested in a money laundering case, and his son-in-law was detained hours after an opposition rally in Karachi. Similar complaints against other party figures were later dropped.

The prime minister insisted that his government and the military were on the same page and that the army should not be blamed for past errors. He accused his predecessor of acting at India's behest, a charge he had made before. The army chief said the military played no role in politics, and a cabinet minister praised its support for democracy, which sat awkwardly with the ruling party's own use of street protests against the previous government in 2014. Claims that critics are serving a hostile neighbour were becoming common across South Asia, and they did little for democratic debate.

The opposition front

Eleven opposition parties had joined in a new alliance, led by the head of a religious party, and rejected claims that they were doing India's bidding. Its rallies criticised the government over poor governance, economic hardship worsened by the pandemic, and an anti-corruption drive that the country's top court had described as one-sided.

Yet the opposition was not united on tactics. Within the former leader's own party and its main ally, many favoured negotiation with the army over confrontation. A private meeting between one senior party figure and the army chief caused an uproar and led to a ban on such contacts.

What to watch

The former prime minister was unlikely to gain directly from his attacks, but he had energised the opposition and strengthened his image as the one leader willing to confront the military. The government was less than halfway through its term and had a mixed record on the economy and foreign policy. Commentators argued that it needed to tolerate legitimate criticism rather than treat dissent as disloyalty, and to show it was more than a front for the security establishment. The army was not expected to let the criticism pass without some form of reprisal.

Why it matters for Australia

Pakistan's political stability matters to security in South Asia and to Australia's wider interest in a calm Indian Ocean region. Civil-military tension in a nuclear-armed state also shaped relations with India, a key partner for Australia.

First published in 2020 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions