Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

Beijing's palm oil pledge and Indonesia's search for new buyers

How a 2018 visit by China's premier to Jakarta produced a promise to buy more Indonesian palm oil just as European markets were turning against the crop.

2018Short analysisIndian Ocean3 min read

Key points

  • China's premier offered to lift Chinese purchases of Indonesian palm oil during a May 2018 visit.
  • European lawmakers had moved to ban palm oil in biofuels, threatening an important export market.
  • Few Indonesian plantations met even national sustainability rules, let alone likely European standards.
  • The extra sales would barely dent Indonesia's large trade deficit with China.

Background

In early May 2018 China's premier made a three-day visit to Jakarta at the invitation of Indonesia's president. Their talks centred on trade and investment, with a particular focus on getting more Indonesian farm products into Chinese markets. The headline result was a promise from Beijing to buy more Indonesian palm oil. The premier then travelled on to Japan for a three-way meeting with Japanese and South Korean leaders.

Why it mattered to Jakarta

At a joint media appearance, the premier said China would raise its palm oil import quota from Indonesia by at least half a million tonnes, a meaningful rise on the previous year's shipments. The timing was welcome. In January 2018 European lawmakers had backed draft climate measures that included banning palm oil from biofuels, a step Malaysia condemned in strong terms. Europe took roughly a sixth of Indonesia's palm oil exports, so any restriction there would hurt.

If Europe did tighten its rules, Indonesia would need other outlets such as China. Meeting European expectations looked unlikely: only a small share of Indonesian plantations complied with the country's own sustainability scheme, which was itself looser than the leading international certification. European legislators had criticised both schemes for failing to curb emissions and stop forest and peat fires, suggesting any future European rules would be tougher still. Shifting sales towards less demanding buyers made commercial sense, but it risked further damage to how buyers worldwide viewed the region's palm oil over time.

Trade balance

The deal also spoke to Indonesian unease over its trade with China. Before the visit, Jakarta signalled it would press for a fairer balance, as it imported far more from China than it sold there, leaving a deficit of about $15 billion in 2017. Against that gap, the additional palm oil sales were small change.

What to watch

The visit closed on a cordial note. It brought no major breakthrough in economic ties, but Beijing took several modest steps to expand trade and to show it was listening to Indonesian concerns, while Jakarta gained a partial hedge against a tougher European market.

Why it matters for Australia

Shifts in palm oil trade between Indonesia, China and Europe affect forest clearing, haze and emissions in Australia's near region. The episode also showed how China used purchasing power to build goodwill with Australia's largest neighbour.

First published in 2018 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions