Key points
- Washington publicly urged Pakistan to act against all militant groups, including those targeting its neighbours.
- Pakistan's army had long used irregular fighters against neighbours, a charge Islamabad rejected.
- Evidence pointed to continued ties between Pakistani security services and Afghan insurgent leaders.
- Better relations with India depended on the army stepping back from foreign policy, which looked unlikely.
Background
In early August 2016 a deputy spokesman for the US foreign affairs department said Washington had told Pakistan's leaders at the highest level that they must go after every militant group on their soil, including those that attacked neighbouring countries, and shut down safe havens. The message was clear: Pakistan was seen as tolerating groups that struck Afghanistan and India. Islamabad's foreign ministry hit back quickly, calling the remarks contradictory and insisting it had taken firm, staged action against terrorism. That response reflected the army's position more than that of the civilian government.
A long pattern
Pakistan's military had relied on irregular forces since the country's birth. In late 1947 it sent armed tribesmen into Kashmir to pressure its ruler to join Pakistan, and in 1965 it infiltrated thousands of soldiers disguised as locals across the line. Both efforts ended in stalemate, after which the army made Kashmir a core national security cause that underpinned its own standing.
Ties with Afghan insurgents followed the same logic. Research published in 2010 found their leaders believed they were directed by Pakistan's military intelligence service. Later events fitted that picture: the movement's founding leader was revealed to have died in a Karachi hospital, its delegates travelled from inside Pakistan to peace talks, a senior adviser to Pakistan's prime minister acknowledged that their leaders and families lived in the country, and in 2016 their next leader was killed by a drone strike in Baluchistan while reportedly carrying Pakistani papers. Afghanistan's president, who had sought better relations, came to describe Pakistan as waging an undeclared war on his country.
India and Kashmir
Militant groups that attacked India also continued to find shelter. Army leaders argued India had ignored a 1948 call by the world body's security council for a vote on Kashmir's future, but the same resolution first asked Pakistan to withdraw tribal fighters and its own nationals, which it had not done.
With India's economy growing fast and the two prime ministers showing they could hold productive talks, the opening was there for the elected leaders to improve relations. The piece argued this required the army to stop using militants as a foreign policy tool, which it judged unlikely.
Why it matters for Australia
Militancy and rivalry between neighbours in South Asia affected the security of the wider Indian Ocean region in which Australia operates. Who really set Pakistan's foreign policy also shaped how Australia and its partners could engage with Islamabad.
First published in 2016 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.
Related from earlier editions
- A New Administration in Washington and What It Meant for Pakistan2021 | Indian Ocean
- After the 2021 Myanmar Coup: Few Good Options for Outside Powers2021 | Indian Ocean
- China deepens its foothold in Djibouti with port money and a carrier-ready pier2021 | Indian Ocean
- Doses and Influence: How China Used Pandemic Vaccines Abroad in 20212021 | Indian Ocean
More from earlier editions
- Earlier analysis sorted by topic Regions
- Earlier short pieces on the Indian Ocean Indian Ocean