Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

Two Asian Lenders, One Winner: Indonesia Plays Tokyo Against Beijing

A 2019 look at how Indonesia used rivalry between Japanese and Chinese investors to win better infrastructure deals, including a new Java rail line.

2019Short analysisIndian Ocean2 min read

Key points

  • In September 2019 Indonesia and Japan agreed to build a faster rail link across Java between Jakarta and Surabaya.
  • Japan had lost an earlier high-speed rail contract to China in 2015.
  • Combined Chinese and Japanese investment in Indonesia grew sharply between 2010 and 2018.
  • Keeping both powers in the race gave Jakarta leverage at a time of slowing growth.

Background

On 24 September 2019, Indonesia and Japan signed a deal for a medium-speed railway linking Jakarta with Surabaya, the main city of East Java. After two years of talks, construction was scheduled to begin in 2020 with completion set for 2025. The line, partly using existing track, was planned to cut the trip by several hours. Japanese loans would fund a project valued at around six billion US dollars, and Indonesian firms were promised a share of the work through technology transfer and local manufacturing.

A rivalry with history

Four years earlier, after a muddled tender, China had won out over Japanese and French bids for a fast line from Jakarta to Bandung. Tokyo, which had already paid for feasibility studies, openly voiced its frustration, and the outcome was widely read as a slight. Indonesian officials soon pointed to the Surabaya route as a second chance, and that tender was restricted to Indonesian and Japanese companies. The new deal could be seen as a gesture of goodwill, but also as a way to keep Japan in the market and competition alive.

Why competition helped Jakarta

Indonesia's growth had slowed since 2010, and a major international lender had warned annual growth might dip under five per cent in 2020. Meanwhile combined investment from China and Japan had climbed from under a billion US dollars in 2010 to several billion by 2018. China's large overseas infrastructure programme fitted Jakarta's development plans, while Japan, keen to counterbalance Beijing and keep its standing in Asia, was promoting high-quality infrastructure, its own technology and better regional links under its vision for an open Indo-Pacific.

Japan also seemed undeterred by delays on its other big Jakarta project, an urban metro whose second stage had been held up by land acquisition. The piece expected more Japanese infrastructure work in Indonesia to follow.

Why it matters for Australia

Competition between China and Japan for Indonesian infrastructure shaped the economic make-up of Australia's nearest large neighbour. It also showed how regional states could draw benefits from great-power rivalry, a dynamic relevant to Australia's own Indo-Pacific diplomacy.

First published in 2019 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions