Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

Keeping Cool Under Threat: Indonesia's Low-Key Approach to Extremism

A May 2016 look at Indonesia's measured response to militancy, from a hostage release in the southern Philippines to prison deradicalisation and online propaganda.

2016Short analysisIndian Ocean2 min read

Key points

  • Ten Indonesian sailors held by militants in the southern Philippines were freed in May 2016.
  • A small but real share of Indonesians expressed sympathy for a Middle East-based extremist group.
  • Deradicalisation in prisons and schools faced criticism after the January 2016 Jakarta attacks.
  • Jakarta preferred calm messaging at home and joint maritime patrols with its neighbours.

Background

On 1 May 2016, ten Indonesian hostages were freed after more than a month in the hands of a kidnap-for-ransom militant group in the Sulu islands of the southern Philippines. Local officials credited growing pressure from the Philippine army, but it was unclear whether money changed hands. The group had a record of killing captives when no payment came, and a local mayor warned that any ransom would simply fund more weapons. Foreign ministers from Indonesia, Malaysia and the Philippines were due to meet in Jakarta days later to plan joint patrols in the Sulu Sea.

The wider extremist threat

Indonesia had been worried for some time about a militant movement based in Iraq and Syria, which in late 2015 had publicly threatened the Indonesian state. A survey the previous year found a small minority of Indonesians held a favourable view of it. The piece suggested that poverty in rural areas helped explain the appeal, as recruiters offered wages, schooling and payments to the families of those killed abroad.

Indonesia's main tool was deradicalisation, delivered through prisons, schools and religious bodies. Critics questioned it after one of the attackers in the January 2016 Jakarta bombings turned out to have been through such a programme. Online propaganda posed a further problem. Blocking websites had proved ineffective and unpopular, so the article favoured counter-messaging, especially campaigns run by Muslim organisations in Muslim-majority countries.

A deliberately calm response

Indonesia had no clear plan for confronting established militant groups across the region, and the article doubted it would adopt a war footing. After the Jakarta attacks, the government had kept its tone subdued, urging people to stay calm rather than vowing retaliation. The same restraint shaped its regional approach, which relied on cooperation with neighbours, shared surveillance and coordinated sea patrols, with more measures possibly to come from the ministers' meeting.

Why it matters for Australia

Militancy in the waters between Indonesia, Malaysia and the Philippines sat close to Australia's northern approaches and its shipping routes. Indonesia's preference for steady, cooperative counter-terrorism shaped how Canberra could work with Jakarta on shared security concerns.

First published in 2016 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions