Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

Two Nuclear Neighbours: Paths Toward a Steadier India-Pakistan Peace

A 2013 survey of what divided India and Pakistan, from Kashmir and river water to Afghanistan, and the practical steps that could ease the rivalry.

2013Long readIndian Ocean3 min read

Key points

  • Kashmir, river water and a nuclear arms race kept the two countries locked in mistrust.
  • Militant attacks repeatedly derailed peace talks and pushed both sides toward war.
  • More trade, shared energy projects and people-to-people contact could build common interests.
  • Confidence-building steps help, but only settling the core disputes would bring lasting stability.

Background: a rivalry born at partition

By 2013, some 65 years after independence, India and Pakistan had still not settled into normal neighbourly relations. Several peace efforts had started and stalled. The piece asked whether the two could follow the post-war reconciliation of France and Germany, and noted that South Asia as a whole had lagged behind South-East Asia partly because its two biggest states remained at odds.

The roots lay in partition. Although both main independence movements had agreed to the legal division of the subcontinent, it came with mass killing, bitter disputes over where the new border was drawn, and a confused process for the princely states. That left Jammu and Kashmir, with its largely Muslim population, in dispute. The dispute had caused wars in 1948 and 1965 and a serious clash in the Kargil heights in 1999, and it drained resources on both sides.

The main sources of friction

  • Water. Pakistan's farms depend on rivers flowing from Kashmir. A treaty brokered in the early 1960s divided the Indus system, but Indian hydropower schemes on rivers allocated to Pakistan revived fears, and demand was rising as supply tightened.
  • Nuclear competition. Some had hoped open nuclear status from 1998 would force restraint. Instead missile and warhead building continued with no overall arms-control framework. India rehearsed rapid offensive war plans from 2004, and Pakistan answered with short-range battlefield nuclear weapons.
  • Militancy. Attacks by armed groups based across the border brought the two close to war in 2001 to 2002 and again in 2008, and halted a broad dialogue process. Each side accused the other of backing insurgents on its soil.
  • Afghanistan. A growing Indian role there made Pakistan fear being squeezed from two sides, and the expected drawdown of Western forces risked turning the country into a new arena for rivalry.

A newly elected Pakistani prime minister had signalled a wish for better ties, but a flare-up along the ceasefire line in Kashmir, amplified ahead of Indian elections, had soured the mood again.

Steps that could help

The paper set out several practical measures. Trade had large untapped potential, and Pakistan seemed close to granting India most-favoured-nation status, though non-tariff barriers and long lists of banned goods also needed work. More legal trade would also cut smuggling.

Energy was another common interest. Both countries suffered chronic power shortages, shown by a massive blackout across northern India in 2012. A proposed gas pipeline from Turkmenistan through Afghanistan gave both a reason to want a stable Afghanistan rather than to compete there.

The confidence-building steps agreed in 1999 had largely run their course, so new ones were needed, along with a way to review whether old agreements were working. Joint arrangements against militancy should be built into lasting institutions rather than left to individual officials. Wider visa access and exchanges between lawmakers could ease ignorance on both sides.

The underlying task

The piece concluded that trade and goodwill would achieve little without real security. India would need to step back from aggressive war-fighting doctrines, and Pakistan from a low nuclear threshold. Outside powers could encourage steady talks, though India preferred to deal directly. In the end, Kashmir itself would have to be resolved.

Why it matters for Australia

Stability between South Asia's two nuclear-armed states mattered to Australia's security and its growing trade and people links with the subcontinent. Any conflict there would have shaken the wider Indian Ocean region in which Australia's interests sit.

First published in 2013 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions