Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

A hard-line vigilante group tests Indonesia's young democracy

How a militant Islamist group's attacks and protests in 2012 raised questions about free expression, the rule of law and religious pluralism in Indonesia.

2012Short analysisIndian Ocean3 min read

Key points

  • A hard-line Islamist group drew headlines in 2012 with attacks, threats and protests against books and concerts.
  • Critics saw the group's ideology and methods as a threat to Indonesia's pluralism, and some critics alleged it could be hired by powerful interests.
  • Political leaders and local communities called for it to be disbanded, but the government cited an outdated law.
  • The case showed that free expression in a young democracy also depends on firm law enforcement.

Background

Indonesia, home to more Muslims than any other country and one of the world's largest democracies, was still adjusting to fast-changing social conditions in 2012. One development drawing attention was the rise of more radical Islamic groups, the most prominent being a hard-line vigilante organisation that styled itself as a defender of the faith.

That year the group caused a series of public controversies. Its members physically attacked a liberal Muslim author from Canada who was in Jakarta to launch a book, pushed a bookshop chain to pull another title it claimed insulted Islam, and threatened to storm a concert by a well-known American pop star, calling her music satanic. The concert was cancelled after police raised security concerns and some lawmakers argued it breached anti-pornography laws. The group had also carried out violent attacks on members of a small minority Muslim sect.

Concerns about the group

Its leaders defended their actions as free expression. Many rights advocates and liberal Indonesians disagreed, warning that the group's beliefs and violent tactics endangered the country's tradition of religious diversity. Some critics described the organisation as partly a business that offered protection to powerful figures under a religious banner, and a media investigation linked such groups to retired police and military officers who used them to pressure the government.

Pressure to act grew. The Dayak community of Central Kalimantan barred the group from visiting, arguing it rejected the unity-in-diversity principle at the heart of the national founding philosophy. A former president and a former vice-president both called for it to be broken up, as did several parties.

The government's response

The government held back. The home affairs ministry said it had sent two formal warnings and could suspend groups that disturbed public order, but a ministry spokesperson argued that disbanding an organisation was legally difficult because the relevant law dated from the mid-1980s and lacked clear procedures, and that updating it would take a long time. Critics suspected the law was being used as an excuse for inaction.

What to watch

The episode suggested that democracy in Indonesia needed both protected freedom of speech and stronger enforcement against violence. With the 2014 presidential election approaching, the group was expected to seek more attention, and failure to respond firmly risked encouraging similar movements and setting a poor precedent.

Why it matters for Australia

Religious tolerance and stable democratic institutions in Indonesia matter directly to Australia's security and its relationship with its largest near neighbour. How Jakarta handled hard-line groups also shaped regional cooperation on extremism.

First published in 2012 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions