Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

Why People Move: Conflict, Wages and a Changing Climate

An overview of the social, political, economic and environmental pressures that push people to leave home and pull them towards particular destinations, with an eye on the Indian Ocean.

2014Long readIndian Ocean4 min read

Key points

  • Migration is driven by push factors at home and pull factors abroad, grouped as social, political, economic and ecological.
  • People fleeing conflict or persecution usually go to the nearest safe country first.
  • Migration between developing countries had grown to rival movement from poorer to richer nations.
  • Climate change was expected to sharpen every other pressure, especially through food and water insecurity.

Background

People leave their countries for many reasons, and analysts usually sort them into push factors, which drive people out, and pull factors, which draw them to a particular place. These fall into four broad groups: social, political, economic and ecological. Social and political shifts are hard to forecast with any precision, though current conditions allow reasonable judgements. Environmental change is easier to anticipate because a large body of science points to growing stress, and by the time of writing in 2014 food and water pressures were already visible in many countries.

Migrants themselves fall into two broad types. Humanitarian migrants, such as refugees and asylum seekers, tend to stay close to home; Afghans fleeing conflict, for instance, had mostly gone to Pakistan and Iran. Economic migrants move for work or better pay, and have more freedom to choose where they go.

Social and political pressures

Persecution on ethnic, religious, racial or cultural grounds, along with war or the threat of it, are among the strongest push factors. Most people who had reached Australia by boat in the preceding decade came from four countries: Iraq, Sri Lanka, Afghanistan and Iran. Three of those had suffered serious conflict, while Iran, though not at war, had a very poor human rights record.

Research suggests that countries moving from authoritarian rule towards democracy face a higher risk of internal conflict, particularly when religion or ethnicity becomes politicised and the state cannot respond well. Several Indian Ocean states, Burma among them, had begun to open up without building a shared national identity. People escaping such turmoil usually seek refuge first in the closest country willing to take them, though some later move on to places offering stronger legal protection.

Economic pressures

Unemployment, poor labour conditions and a weak economy all encourage people to leave, often first from the countryside to the cities. International economic migrants are most often drawn from middle-income nations in which education is rising faster than wages, creating an incentive for skilled workers to seek better pay abroad. Historically most of this flow ran from poorer to richer nations, but movement between developing countries had grown until it roughly matched that flow. Most of it occurs between neighbouring states with shared cultures, because the barriers are lower and the disruption smaller.

Cheaper travel, better communications and more open labour markets also made repeat, back-and-forth migration easier. Such circular migrants tend to send more money home and reduce the loss of skilled workers, though protection against exploitation remained weak.

The climate multiplier

Climate change was seen as the most serious ecological driver, mainly because it intensifies the other pressures. Land that can no longer support farming forces people to find new work or move, sometimes bringing previously separate ethnic or religious groups into contact and competition. Rising food and water prices strain the capacity of states to keep order. The international climate science panel had judged that the largest effects on food security would arrive around mid-century, with poorer countries least able to adapt.

People displaced by environmental change are often called climate refugees, but international refugee law does not recognise that label, and many agencies prefer environmental migrants. The analysis argued that governments should use the coming decade to prepare for larger movements, treating migration itself as one form of adaptation.

Why it matters for Australia

Australia receives both economic migrants and asylum seekers from across the Indian Ocean region, so the pressures driving people from home shape its immigration and border policies. Growing food and water stress in nearby countries made environmental migration a long-term planning question for Australia.

First published in 2014 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions