Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

Oil, rivals and restless youth: the pressures on Saudi Arabia in 2014

A survey of the external and domestic strains facing the Saudi kingdom in 2014, from shifting oil markets and regional rivalries to jobs, water and schooling.

2014Long readIndian Ocean3 min read

Key points

  • Energy made up more than nine-tenths of Saudi exports, and new American and Russian supply threatened its markets.
  • A thaw between Washington and Tehran and closer US ties with Turkey risked leaving Riyadh more isolated.
  • Extremist violence in neighbouring Iraq and Yemen raised the security threat at home.
  • Youth unemployment, scarce water and an uneven school system fed quiet discontent.

Background

In 2014 Saudi Arabia was the world's largest oil exporter, and energy products accounted for more than nine-tenths of its export earnings. That dependence left the kingdom exposed. Its prosperity, and the legitimacy of the ruling family, rested on oil revenue at a time when the market around it was changing quickly.

Outside pressures

New drilling technology had turned the United States into the world's biggest oil producer, sharply cutting its need for Saudi crude and opening the prospect of American exports competing head to head. Asian buyers such as China, Japan, South Korea and India had become Riyadh's main customers. Russia, meanwhile, had grown wary of Europe after the crisis over Crimea and turned east, signing a huge energy deal with China and promising more oil and a new gas pipeline. Beijing, keen to reduce its reliance on sea lanes through the Malacca Strait, had good reason to buy more from its neighbour, which could squeeze Saudi sales to its largest market.

Regional rivalry added to the strain. Riyadh and Tehran had long been at odds, partly over sectarian differences and partly over the Saudi claim to legitimacy as guardian of Islam's holiest sites. Tentative progress in nuclear talks raised the chance that sanctions on Iran would ease. With less need for Saudi oil, Washington had a freer hand in the region and appeared to be paying more attention to Jordan and Turkey. Turkey, a Muslim-majority democracy with a large army inside the Western military alliance, competed with Riyadh for leadership of the Sunni world and backed a transnational Islamist movement that the kingdom had outlawed as a terrorist group, fearing it could stir revolt at home as it had in Egypt in 2011.

Extremists were also gaining ground in Iraq and Yemen. A self-declared Islamic caliphate group had threatened to strike the kingdom, and a regional branch of a global jihadist network had tried before from Yemen, so security forces were on high alert.

Pressures at home

Discontent had grown since the regional uprisings of 2011. New counter-terrorism laws were broad enough to treat peaceful critics as terrorists, and rights groups argued that protesters were the real target. Many Saudis turned to social media to voice complaints. The Shia minority, concentrated in the oil-rich east, reported widespread discrimination, and Riyadh feared Iranian meddling there.

Nearly half the population was under 25, and youth unemployment sat at around one in eight. Foreign workers filled most new jobs because they were better trained, and strict religious rules limited work for women. Water was another weak point. The desert kingdom relied on old wells, desalination plants, small dams and recycling schemes, yet cities such as Jeddah were already trucking in water during shortages.

Schooling posed perhaps the hardest problem. Literacy among young people was very high, but public schools leaned on rote learning, gender segregation hampered teaching, and the best education was in costly private schools, creating a two-tier workforce and fuelling resentment.

What to watch

None of these challenges was beyond repair, but each called for prompt action. A government seen to tackle jobs, water and education would earn more support at home, leaving it better placed to handle the shifts in oil markets and regional power around it.

Why it matters for Australia

Saudi Arabia sits at the western edge of the Indian Ocean and its stability affects oil prices, Gulf shipping and the wider region that Australia trades with. Shifts in who buys and sells energy across Asia also shaped the markets for Australia's own energy exports.

First published in 2014 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions