Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

Indonesia's Militant Threat in 2016: Small, Patient and Changing

A conflict researcher based in Jakarta on how Indonesia recruited and deradicalised militants, the long game of an older network, and a distant risk on the Bangladesh-Myanmar border.

2016Long readIndian Ocean3 min read

Key points

  • For a country of its size, Indonesia had a small and mostly ineffective militant movement.
  • Deradicalisation efforts often rested on guesswork rather than an understanding of how recruitment worked.
  • An older network had rebuilt itself and was not expected to strike soon, but it planned over decades.
  • Foreigners were again seen as targets, though a deliberate attack on Australian interests was judged unlikely.

Background

Indonesia, the world's largest Muslim-majority nation, has long faced violent extremism, yet relative to its population the militant movement there was small and largely unsuccessful. In 2016, with perhaps a couple of hundred Indonesians believed to be fighting with an extremist movement in the Middle East, a Jakarta-based conflict researcher set out how she saw the main risks for Indonesia and its neighbours.

Recruitment and its remedies

Recruitment, she explained, happened mostly face to face, above all in urban mosques and to a lesser extent in schools. Those drawn in were not mainly the very poor. Some were graduates, but many were street vendors and other underemployed, highly mobile people. Before worrying about fighters coming home, she argued, authorities should identify known recruiting sites and offer appealing alternative activities that steer the same people towards something constructive.

The weakness of existing programmes was that they were not built on real knowledge of how people became radical. Some officials with military backgrounds assumed the problem was weak patriotism and responded with lessons in the state ideology, an approach linked to the old authoritarian era. The real issue, in her view, was preachers persuading followers that a hard-line reading of the faith was the only proper way to live, and that message had to be contested directly.

Former prisoners could help. One man convicted over the 2002 Bali bombings had come to argue that violence was counterproductive, though not that it was wrong, and had persuaded others. Such figures had limited shelf life: once long out of the networks, their sway over new arrests faded.

A movement in transition

For some years, would-be attackers had been recruited off the street with little training or planning, and lacked the combat experience earlier militants had gained in the communal conflicts in Maluku and Central Sulawesi. That was changing. The rise of the Middle Eastern extremist movement had re-energised some older militants, including some leaving prison, which could raise the movement's capability even before returnees arrived.

An older regional network that had renounced violence inside Indonesia from about 2007 had largely rebuilt itself and appeared to be shifting back towards military preparation, with recent arrests for training and stockpiling weapons. It was not expected to attack soon, but it thought in spans of a quarter-century, and nobody could say what might change its calculation.

Risks to foreigners and the region

The researcher saw renewed interest in targeting foreigners, mainly soft targets such as restaurants and tourist sites, or knife attacks on individuals. A deliberate strike on Australian businesses or symbols was considered unlikely. Links between pro-extremist groups in Indonesia, Malaysia and the southern Philippines were growing, and as travel to Syria grew harder, some Indonesians might turn to Mindanao instead.

What to watch

Looking further ahead, she flagged the plight of the Rohingya. There was no visible extremist group among them at the time, but with a large refugee population in Bangladesh and worsening conditions there, a militant camp on the border attracting fighters from across South-East Asia was a remote but real possibility.

Why it matters for Australia

Indonesia is Australia's largest near neighbour, so the direction of its militant movement was a direct concern for Australian security planning. The judgement that Australian interests faced a low risk, while threats to soft targets and cross-border links were growing, framed how that danger was understood at the time.

First published in 2016 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions