Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

Between Two Giants: How Kazakhstan Balanced China and Russia

Why Kazakhstan sat at the centre of China's westward push into Central Asia, and how its balancing act between Beijing and Moscow could guide its neighbours.

2019Short analysisIndian Ocean3 min read

Key points

  • Central Asia offered China markets, resources and a route west away from pressure on its Pacific flank.
  • China had overtaken Russia as the region's main economic partner, while Russia still led on security.
  • Kazakhstan welcomed Chinese money but limited land sales and visas amid public unease.
  • Its effort to keep both neighbours at arm's length could set a pattern for the rest of the region.

Background

The Pacific remained Beijing's first priority, but Central Asia had grown steadily more important to China. The region offered markets, energy and minerals, overland transport corridors and security partners across a vast interior, and a westward focus let China avoid some of the resistance it met from the United States and its allies in East Asia. Chinese investment in the region had grown more than a hundredfold since the early 1990s, and by 2018 China was widely seen as having overtaken Russia as Central Asia's main economic partner.

For years an informal split of roles held: Moscow led on politics and security, Beijing on trade and investment. That arrangement was starting to blur. A Chinese military presence in Tajikistan and growing arms sales to Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan showed China moving into security matters, something Moscow tolerated quietly while its own tensions with Washington pushed it closer to Beijing.

Why Kazakhstan mattered

Kazakhstan, the largest landlocked country in the world, was the linchpin of China's westward strategy. Beijing's interests combined border security, especially concerns linked to Xinjiang, with energy supply and transport routes. Chinese investment had flowed into Kazakh oil, mining, transport and farming, and the country hoped to use China's large overseas infrastructure programme to diversify its economy and reach world markets.

Closer ties brought friction. Many Kazakhs distrusted China, a feeling sharpened by limited transparency and by the detention of ethnic Kazakhs in Xinjiang. The government responded by restricting Chinese land ownership, tightening visas and, in 2019, publicising the arrest of a senior adviser accused of spying for China.

What to watch

Kazakhstan showed the same caution towards Russia, its former ruler and closest partner, keeping its own positions in regional forums and moving to a Latin-based alphabet. By courting investment from Europe and the United States as well, it gained room to bargain. How well it guarded its sovereignty as competition between Moscow and Beijing grew was expected to shape how other Central Asian states dealt with both.

Why it matters for Australia

Central Asia lies far from Australia, but China's westward expansion was part of the same push that brought its investment and influence into the Indian Ocean region. How smaller states balanced Chinese economic ties against sovereignty concerns offered a useful comparison for Australia's own neighbourhood.

First published in 2019 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions