Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Indian Ocean

From an earlier edition

Two Asian Powers, Two Playbooks: Competing for Influence in Africa

How China and Japan pursued influence in Africa in 2019 by different means, with Beijing favouring fast infrastructure and Tokyo stressing local skills and stability.

2019Short analysisIndian Ocean3 min read

Key points

  • Japan used its regular Africa development summit to grow influence and counter China's reach.
  • Chinese finance came with few political conditions but often relied on Chinese goods and labour.
  • Japan focused on training local people, stability and building local production.
  • Tokyo's approach was slower to show results but looked more durable.

Background

In late August 2019 Japan hosted the seventh round of its long-running summit on African development in Yokohama. The meeting was a key soft-power tool for Tokyo, and also a way to push back against China's expanding presence on the continent. Japan had already exceeded the roughly US$30 billion in investment it pledged at the previous summit in 2016, with more expected from private firms. Its prime minister spoke of building a strategic partnership with African states rather than a simple donor and recipient arrangement. Japan could not match China's spending, but it aimed for a relationship built on quality and human development.

Beijing's model

Each power ran its own Africa forum, and both sought to advance national interests. The difference lay in the terms. Chinese investment typically came without political conditions or interference in domestic affairs, which suited governments wary of outside pressure. It also leaned heavily on Chinese materials, firms and workers, a way to absorb surplus production at home, but one that left local labour and industry underused. Beijing saw infrastructure as the shortcut to prosperity, yet its approach did little to build local capability. Financial strain in China had also slowed some of its African plans, and railways in East Africa faced doubts about their viability.

Tokyo's alternative

Japan stepped into that gap, raising investment while helping countries develop their own production. Its main aid agency aimed to spark lasting local growth through two priorities. The first was training people so they could maintain and eventually build infrastructure themselves; a Japanese-built bridge in the Democratic Republic of Congo was kept in service by Japanese expertise even through conflict. The second was tackling the social problems that fuel instability. In South Sudan, Japan funded safer mining and new farmland, and in Nigeria it sought to build a local food production chain, including fertiliser plants suited to local soils.

Outlook

China prioritised speed and scale, often without much thought for long-term viability or local development. Japan's path was likely to take longer to deliver, but its focus on people and skills offered better odds of steady growth.

Why it matters for Australia

Africa's Indian Ocean coast forms part of the wider maritime region Australia cares about, and Japan was one of Australia's closest partners in the Indo-Pacific. How Tokyo and Beijing competed for influence offered lessons for Australia's own development and infrastructure choices with neighbours.

First published in 2019 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions