Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Water and Food

From an earlier edition

Running Dry and Running Dirty: The State of Pakistan's Water in 2019

How drought, thirsty farming, pollution and outdated water laws left Pakistan facing an acute water crisis in 2019, and what its new national water policy could change.

2019Long readWater and Food4 min read

Key points

  • Pakistan faced worsening water scarcity, driven by drought, heavy groundwater pumping and water-hungry farming.
  • Sewage, industrial waste and farm chemicals left much of the population without clean water.
  • Colonial-era laws, weak enforcement and overlapping agencies undermined water management.
  • A new national water policy in 2018 was a milestone, but its vague wording limited what it could achieve.

Background

Pakistan sits on the Indus system and holds vast glacier reserves, yet by early 2019 it was widely described as heading towards absolute water scarcity. During 2018 its two largest reservoirs fell to or near the level at which they could no longer operate, and the new government launched a public crowdfunding drive to pay for more dams, an approach that looked unrealistic.

Dry and semi-dry land covers most of Pakistan, and large parts get very little rain in a typical year, and drought gripped Sindh and Balochistan after failed winter and monsoon rains. Snow and glacier melt supply a large part of the Indus flow, and a changing climate was making that melt, and the flooding risk that comes with it, less predictable. Surface water per person had dropped from over five thousand cubic metres in the early 1950s to around a thousand by 2016. Groundwater was being pumped well beyond sustainable rates, and by one measure Pakistan's economy used more water per unit of output than any other.

Storage, farming and waste

The country could store only about a month of river flow, which left it short in the dry season and exposed to floods in the wet. Silt had also eaten into reservoir capacity. Agriculture employed most of the workforce, directly or indirectly, and used over nine tenths of the nation's water, mostly on wheat, sugarcane, rice and cotton. Flood irrigation through unlined channels wasted large volumes. As canal supplies became unreliable, farmers turned to wells, and falling water tables in Punjab and Sindh made the Indus aquifer one of the most stressed on Earth.

A quality crisis

Just over half of the population had safe drinking water, and in rural areas most people lacked it. Unclean water was linked to a large share of illness and deaths. Only two cities had biological sewage treatment, and neither worked properly; even at full capacity they could handle a small fraction of the country's wastewater. Septic tanks drained into open channels, and waste from latrines often ended up in rivers and fields, so diarrhoeal disease was most common in the countryside. Textile mills, tanneries and the big industrial estates around Karachi released heavy metals and oil straight into waterways, helped by lax enforcement and concessions designed to protect export earnings. Fertiliser and pesticide runoff added to the load. Naturally occurring arsenic in Indus groundwater put tens of millions of people at risk, and heavy pumping was making aquifers saltier.

Governance and the new policy

Water management rested on outdated colonial-era laws, a habit of favouring giant engineering works, and loosely defined rights often tied to land ownership. Infrastructure followed a cycle of building, neglecting and rebuilding. Water was handled by the provinces, and a 1991 sharing agreement had eased some disputes, but the body meant to apply it could not monitor flows and was widely criticised as supplies shrank. Later reforms piled new agencies with overlapping roles on top of old ones.

In 2018 the federal and provincial leadership finally approved a national water policy, which earmarked a tenth of federal development funds for water infrastructure and set goals to cut losses. It was a genuine step forward, but critics said it contained so many recommendations that parts were vague or contradictory. Without stronger governance and enforcement, little was likely to change.

Why it matters for Australia

Pakistan's struggle to share a single great river between provinces mirrored long-running debates over Australia's own interstate river basin. Its water and food troubles also mattered for stability in South Asia, a region of growing interest to Australian trade and diplomacy.

First published in 2019 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions