Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Water and Food

From an earlier edition

Contained Virus, Emptier Plates: South-East Asia's Pandemic Food Squeeze

How South-East Asian countries handled Covid-19 in 2020, and why even the successful ones saw incomes fall and household food and nutrition slip.

2020Long readWater and Food3 min read

Key points

  • Most of the region kept infections low through fast, firm action, with Indonesia and the Philippines the main exceptions.
  • Lockdowns brought recessions to almost every economy in the region except Vietnam.
  • Movement limits cut farm labour and rural incomes, pushing many families back towards poverty.
  • Food supplies were broadly adequate, but many households could no longer afford enough to eat.

Background

South-East Asia had made real gains in food security over the two decades before the pandemic. Strong growth, rising farm output and better rural incomes had cut undernourishment faster than in any other region since the early 1990s. Even so, poverty remained deep in parts of the region, and about 60 million people were still undernourished when Covid-19 arrived in early 2020.

Two paths through the pandemic

The virus reached the region earlier than most of the world, yet most governments kept it in check. Vietnam stood out. Despite modest health infrastructure and a population similar in size to the Philippines, it recorded only around a thousand cases through most of 2020. It closed its border with China early, developed its own tests, isolated every infected person in hospital and traced contacts several steps out. Thailand, the first country outside China to detect a case, also kept numbers low through early screening of arrivals, an early lockdown and widespread mask use, and Cambodia and Laos fared similarly.

Indonesia and the Philippines were the exceptions. Both saw cases climb into the hundreds of thousands by late 2020, largely because of weak early management. In Indonesia, some senior officials promoted unproven remedies and testing was among the lowest anywhere. In the Philippines, a response led by retired generals rather than health experts, a long lockdown, low testing and workers returning to the provinces helped carry the virus beyond the cities.

The economic cost

Controlling the virus came at an economic price. Thailand's tourism and export economy suffered its sharpest fall since the late-1990s financial crisis, millions lost jobs, many without social protection, and the downturn fed into street protests. The Philippines faced the steepest contraction in the region as lockdowns crushed household spending and remittances from workers abroad dropped. Indonesia and Singapore were expected to see milder recessions. Only Vietnam, able to reopen quickly, looked set to keep growing.

From lost income to less food

The region had enough food overall; the problem was access. Movement restrictions reduced the farm workforce and trimmed agricultural output in economies where farming is a leading employer, especially Laos, Myanmar, Timor-Leste and Vietnam. In Myanmar, about three in four farming households reported lower incomes than the year before. Across the wider region, tens of millions were expected to fall into poverty, including many who would otherwise have escaped it, raising the prospect of the first rise in regional poverty in two decades.

Households responded by eating less. Surveys in Indonesia found many families cutting meals for lack of money, and in the Philippines a large majority of households had reduced how much they ate. Some Indonesian provinces also ran short of staples as supply chains faltered.

What to watch

Nutrition was the deeper worry. About a quarter of young children in the region were already stunted, and iron deficiency was common among women. School closures removed free meals that many poor children relied on, and disruption to fresh food supplies threatened access to nutrient-rich produce, suggesting the health effects of the crisis could outlast the virus itself.

Why it matters for Australia

South-East Asia is Australia's closest regional neighbourhood, so falling incomes and worsening food insecurity there bore directly on regional stability and the demand for support. The pandemic showed how quickly hard-won gains in food security can be reversed, a lesson relevant to Australian aid and agricultural planning.

First published in 2020 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions