Key points
- Pakistan grew more food than it needed, but poverty and food inflation kept nutritious diets out of reach for most households.
- Child stunting, wasting and vitamin and mineral shortages were among the worst in the world.
- Population growth, thirsty crops and a leaky irrigation network were draining water supplies.
- Most people lacked safe drinking water, making water-borne disease a leading cause of death.
A surplus that did not reach the table
At the time of writing in early 2020, Pakistan had a population of about 204 million and ranked among the world's big producers of wheat, rice, milk and livestock. Rice was its main farm export earner and most farmland relied on a vast but ageing irrigation network. A dry 2018-19 season had cut crop output, yet the country still produced a food surplus and supply was steady.
The problem was access. Roughly two thirds of households could not afford a nutritious diet built around wheat, the national staple, and the share was far higher in Balochistan. Almost a quarter of the population lived below the national poverty line, rising in rural areas. Food prices had jumped sharply in the year to early 2020, hitting the rural poor hardest, and calorie intake had actually fallen over the previous decade and a half despite rising household spending on food.
A malnutrition crisis
Few countries had worse malnutrition among mothers and young children than Pakistan. More than four in ten children were stunted, the share suffering from wasting was above the emergency threshold set by global health authorities, and deficiencies in vitamin A, zinc, iodine and iron were widespread. Anaemia affected about half of women and an even larger share of children. Even wealthier families were not spared. The costs went beyond health: stunting was linked to poorer schooling and lower adult earnings, and high food prices had contributed to repeated bouts of unrest, while hunger fed resentment in Balochistan that militants exploited.
A national food security policy, years in the drafting, had been approved in 2018 just before a change of government. Little had been done with it since, whether because of its link to the previous administration or because of the economic crisis. Meanwhile a locust plague, inflation, job losses and food shortages were adding pressure, and a commodity subsidy worked out to only a few cents a person each month.
Water under strain
Most of the country's surface and groundwater lies in the Indus basin, and most of the land is arid or semi-arid, with rain concentrated in a few summer months. Pakistan was both water scarce and water stressed. Water available per person had fallen to under a quarter of its level fifty years earlier, while demand kept climbing. Groundwater was heavily drawn down in parts of Punjab and Balochistan.
Farming took over nine tenths of all water, well above the global norm, and four thirsty crops (wheat, rice, sugarcane and cotton) used most of it while adding little to national output. The canal system lost more than half its water to seepage, leaks and flood irrigation. Climate change was expected to make river flows less predictable, raising the risk of both floods and droughts.
Unsafe water
Only about a fifth of Pakistanis had safe drinking water. Most relied on supplies tainted by sewage, farm chemicals or industrial waste, and aquifers in Punjab and Sindh held arsenic and other heavy metals. Treatment capacity was tiny and sanitation for rural and poor urban areas almost non-existent, so water-borne illness caused a large share of disease and deaths. Without tackling the political and economic roots of these problems, little change looked likely.
Why it matters for Australia
Pakistan was a significant grain and rice producer in a region where Australia sells food and farm expertise, and its water troubles echoed problems in Australia's own heavily irrigated basins. Food and water stress in a populous South Asian state also bore on the stability of the wider Indian Ocean region.
First published in 2020 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.
Related from earlier editions
- Contained Virus, Emptier Plates: South-East Asia's Pandemic Food Squeeze2020 | Water and Food
- Dams and Erratic Flows on the Mekong at the Start of 20202020 | Water and Food
- Why the world's water demand looked set to outrun supply by 20502020 | Water and Food
- Enough Calories, Too Few Nutrients: India's Food Security Puzzle2019 | Water and Food
More from earlier editions
- Earlier analysis sorted by topic Regions