Key points
- A draft national water law aimed to bring in usage fees and a single management system across Thailand.
- Farm groups called it a water tax, even though most smallholders looked likely to be exempt.
- Rising rural debt and falling land ownership made farmers especially sensitive to new costs.
- A constitution favouring the military limited how much opposition parties could gain from the dispute.
Background
In late 2017 Thailand's environment ministry was preparing a draft national water law, due to be completed early the following year. The bill set out to create a uniform system for managing water across the country and to charge fees to industries drawing from rivers, lakes and aquifers. Successive governments had tried to introduce similar rules since the early 1990s, but none had succeeded in a country where water carries deep cultural meaning and farmers are regarded as the heart of rural society.
Under the rules then in force, anyone could pump surface or groundwater according to their own judgement of need. With demand from different sectors already exceeding supply and still rising, that free-for-all could not last, and the new law was intended to share scarce water more fairly and manage it better.
Why farmers objected
Farm organisations branded the proposal a water tax that would push up costs, and the head of a national farmers' body argued that rain falls free and so should not be charged for. Smallholders with little land and thin margins were seen as most at risk.
In practice, most small farmers looked unlikely to pay. The draft sorted users into three tiers, with heavier users charged more. Prices were not fixed, but one proposal would have charged only rice growers with larger holdings, a small fee per cubic metre. Since most Thai farmers work far smaller plots, the majority would have been exempt. Even so, fears persisted that charging for farm water could undermine small-scale agriculture.
Those fears drew strength from rural hardship. Household debt had climbed steeply through the early 2010s and was among the highest in South-East Asia, and the share of farmers who owned the land they worked had dropped sharply over the previous decade.
What to watch
The two main opposition parties, both weakened, opposed the bill on cost grounds and could use farm anger to their advantage. Elections were pencilled in for late 2018 but could easily be delayed. A new constitution adopted in 2017 handed the military wide influence, bound future governments to a long-term development plan drawn up by the junta, and installed a military-appointed senate. That meant any public backlash over the water law was unlikely to translate into real gains for the opposition.
Why it matters for Australia
Thailand is a significant trading partner and competitor in rice and other farm exports, so its water rules and rural politics affected regional agricultural markets. The debate also echoed Australia's own experience of introducing water charges and allocation limits for farmers.
First published in 2017 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.
Related from earlier editions
- Contained Virus, Emptier Plates: South-East Asia's Pandemic Food Squeeze2020 | Water and Food
- Dams and Erratic Flows on the Mekong at the Start of 20202020 | Water and Food
- Plenty of Grain, Too Little to Eat: Pakistan's Food and Water Squeeze2020 | Water and Food
- Why the world's water demand looked set to outrun supply by 20502020 | Water and Food
More from earlier editions
- Earlier analysis sorted by topic Regions
- Earlier short pieces on global food and water Water and Food