Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Water and Food

From an earlier edition

Enough Calories, Too Few Nutrients: India's Food Security Puzzle

Why India, self-sufficient in staple grains and running one of the largest food aid schemes anywhere, still struggled with malnutrition, water mismanagement and wasteful farm subsidies in 2019.

2019Long readWater and Food3 min read

Key points

  • Food rationing schemes dating from the 1940s ensured most Indians had enough to eat, but diets lacked variety.
  • Poor water management in the northern farm states that grow much of India's food posed a long-term risk.
  • Fuel and fertiliser subsidies favoured large landholders, encouraged waste and did little for yields.
  • India was broadly food secure in 2019, but these pressures could erode that over time.

Background

Food security is usually judged on four tests: whether enough food exists, whether people can obtain it, whether it nourishes them, and whether that holds steady over time. By the first measure India had long succeeded. It reached self-sufficiency in grain during the 1970s and had produced enough calories for its whole population since the mid-1990s. It led the world in milk, pulses and millets and ranked second in rice, wheat, sugarcane, fruit and vegetables.

A ration system set up in the 1940s after a run of famines bought grain from farmers at guaranteed prices and sold it cheaply to consumers. It was narrowed to poorer households in 1997, then expanded again by a 2013 food rights law that let some 800 million eligible people buy small monthly quantities of rice, wheat and coarse grains for a few rupees a kilogram. Government buying was so large that storage could not keep up, and grain was lost to pests and rain. India's attachment to the scheme also complicated global trade talks.

The nutrition gap

Despite this, malnutrition remained stubborn. Over a third of young children were underweight, around a fifth were wasted, about half of women of child-bearing age were anaemic and most people fell short on vitamins. Across South Asia, economic growth and falling poverty had done less for nutrition than in much poorer countries elsewhere, a pattern sometimes called the South Asian enigma. India's programmes were generous with calories but did little to diversify diets. In 2018 the government began adding millets to the ration system, and better education about varied diets could help.

Water and productivity

Most Indian farms depend on rain, chiefly the south-west monsoon from June to September, while the later north-east monsoon matters most for the southern states. A warming Indian Ocean could weaken the main monsoon. A government think tank had warned that the country faced its worst water crisis on record, with demand expected to double available supply by 2030. Agriculture used the great bulk of the nation's water, and as rivers became polluted or out of reach farmers pumped more groundwater, putting many aquifers on course for a critical state. The northern states that scored worst on water management, including Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Bihar and Haryana, were home to about half the population and grew a large share of its food.

India had more cropland than any other country, yet its yields lagged well behind those of China and the United States. A 2016 economic review called for drip and sprinkler irrigation, a shift to pulses and oilseeds, and renewed research, but little had followed.

Subsidies that misfire

A large slice of the national budget went on holding down food prices, supporting farmers and keeping out imports. Fuel and fertiliser subsidies mostly helped big landowners, although most farmers worked less than a hectare, too little to feed a family. Support also kept farmers growing crops such as sugar even when markets were oversupplied. India's problem had shifted from too little food to too little variety, while water stress, climate change, low productivity and wasteful farming threatened future security.

Why it matters for Australia

India was among the largest producers of grains and pulses anywhere, so its farm subsidies and trade barriers mattered to Australian food exporters. Its water and productivity challenges also created openings for Australian expertise in dryland farming and irrigation efficiency.

First published in 2019 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions