Future Directions Review
Home/Earlier editions/Water and Food

From an earlier edition

Full Granaries, Empty Plates: Why Pakistan Stayed Hungry in 2019

Why Pakistan, despite producing more food than it needed and exporting wheat, still had some of the world's worst rates of hunger and child malnutrition in 2019.

2019Long readWater and Food3 min read

Key points

  • Pakistan grew a food surplus, yet most households were judged food insecure.
  • Poverty and rising food prices, not supply, were the main barriers to an adequate diet.
  • High wheat support prices did little for the rural poor, most of whom do not grow wheat.
  • Debt, likely loan conditions and frequent disasters threatened plans to cut hunger.

Background

Pakistan, a country of modest middle incomes, has one of the largest populations in the world. By 2019 a run of strong harvests meant it produced more food than it consumed, and it had recently shipped a record volume of wheat abroad. Yet an international food relief agency judged that some three in five people faced food insecurity, and the country's progress on reducing undernourishment was among the weakest in South Asia.

The burden fell hardest on women and children. Close to half of young children were stunted, wasting had reached emergency levels in some districts, and very few malnourished children could get treatment. Feeding practices in infancy were often poor, with low rates of breastfeeding in the early months and limited variety in the diets of toddlers, linked to poverty, illiteracy and in some cases attitudes toward daughters. Deficiencies in iron, vitamin A and zinc were widespread across all income groups, raising the risk of illness and death for mothers and infants.

A problem of access

The core issue was not supply but the ability to buy food. Wages had risen over the previous decade, but food prices had climbed faster, eroding what households could afford. Average calorie intake fell well below recommended levels, and poor rural families fared worst. The average household spent about half its income on food, and poorer ones even more, leaving them exposed to any price rise.

Wheat, which provides around half of the calories Pakistanis eat, was central to the problem. The government kept domestic wheat prices above world levels to support farm incomes. In practice this helped mainly larger growers in Punjab, where most of the crop is produced. Many small farmers lacked storage, so they sold at harvest and bought back later at higher prices, and most of the rural poor were landless or lived in households that did not farm at all. For them, dearer wheat simply meant dearer bread.

Shocks and fragility

Pakistan's food security had worsened since the 2000s under a series of overlapping crises: the aftermath of the global financial crisis, fuel and food price spikes, conflict on its frontiers, political instability and a harsh climate. Food inflation lingered longer than in most countries. The country is highly exposed to climate risks, from floods in the north and centre to cyclones on the coast and drought in the south. Floods had become far more frequent, the 2010 disaster left poor rural families slow to recover, and a long drought in Sindh drove many households into debt even though markets still had food.

What to watch

In 2018 Pakistan adopted its first national food security policy, promising to reduce poverty and end hunger through federal and provincial co-operation and a zero-hunger programme. A large anti-poverty scheme followed. Both faced serious obstacles. Trust between Islamabad and some provinces was weak, little had yet been put into practice, and public debt was consuming a growing share of the budget. The government was negotiating an emergency loan from a global lender, which was expected to bring austerity and a weaker currency, likely pushing up the cost of imported food just as inflation had eased. Without room to spend on the poor, pressure on the most vulnerable seemed set to grow.

Why it matters for Australia

Pakistan's experience showed that national food surpluses do not guarantee household food security, a lesson relevant to Australia's aid and agricultural trade in South Asia. Instability in a populous, nuclear-armed Indian Ocean state also bore on the wider region Australia depends on.

First published in 2019 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.

Related from earlier editions

More from earlier editions