Key points
- Import restrictions meant to boost local farming mostly produced shortages and higher prices.
- A fast-growing middle class wanted more meat, dairy and processed food than local farms could supply.
- Moving food between thousands of islands was one of the biggest barriers to food security.
- Fisheries and modernised aquaculture offered Indonesia its clearest food advantage.
Background: self-sufficiency as policy
Indonesia had long tied food security to growing its own staples, especially rice, and to producing more high-value foods such as beef. As of early 2016 the results were mixed. The country had once grown enough rice and sugar for itself, but output did not keep pace with population. Farmers shifted to lucrative non-food crops such as oil palm, and factories and housing took over farmland.
Agriculture's share of the economy had shrunk, yet around two in five workers still earned a living from it, and roughly a third of the land was farmed. Few young people were entering the sector, with only a small fraction of farmers under 35, raising worries about future labour and innovation.
What changed after 2014
Indonesia had made real progress against hunger since 2000, though more slowly than Thailand or Vietnam. A target to source nearly all food at home by 2014 was missed, as most food farmers worked small plots and a more erratic climate added risk. The president elected in 2014 cut or delayed imports of sugar, beef, corn and rice to spur local supply. Instead, shortages and price spikes followed.
Demand was also changing. The middle class was among the world's largest and expanding, and better-off households buy more meat, milk and packaged food. Undernourishment had roughly halved since 1990, but obesity was climbing, and childhood stunting had risen again between 2005 and 2015, with lasting effects on health, schooling and earnings.
Islands, land and beef
Spread across thousands of inhabited islands, Indonesia found moving food from where it was grown to where it was eaten very hard. The government's maritime agenda aimed to turn the seas into links rather than barriers. A purpose-built cattle ship began carrying livestock from outer islands to Java in 2015, though its monthly load fell far short of the capital's daily needs, and more ships and better ports were planned. Results would take years and heavy spending.
Expanding farmland also caused friction. Land disputes, many linked to plantation expansion, had cost dozens of lives over the previous decade, and new clearing in outer islands with a history of distrust toward Jakarta risked more conflict.
On beef, Indonesia was looking beyond its main supplier, which provided about four fifths of imports. Alternatives raised disease concerns, and a plan for quarantine islands would add weeks to supply chains and push prices up. The piece doubted shoppers would accept higher costs for a possibly lower-quality product.
The fisheries opportunity
Fish was where Indonesia stood out. Indonesians ate far more fish than the global average, it supplied over half their animal protein, and on remote islands almost all of it. Illegal fishing had depleted stocks. From late 2014 the fisheries minister banned large foreign vessels and at-sea transfers, curbed commercial fishing and sank illegal boats, and the sector reportedly grew strongly afterwards.
Aquaculture, practised in the archipelago for centuries, could steady supply as wild catches came under pressure, but nearly all production still came from small traditional fishers. Modernising it could strengthen food security and open export earnings. The article concluded that Indonesia would keep relying on imports, and that better connections between islands would serve it better than closing the door to foreign food.
Why it matters for Australia
Australia was Indonesia's dominant beef supplier, so Jakarta's import curbs and diversification plans bore directly on northern cattle producers. Shared fishing waters and Indonesia's food demand also kept agriculture central to the relationship.
First published in 2016 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.
Related from earlier editions
- Contained Virus, Emptier Plates: South-East Asia's Pandemic Food Squeeze2020 | Water and Food
- Dams and Erratic Flows on the Mekong at the Start of 20202020 | Water and Food
- Plenty of Grain, Too Little to Eat: Pakistan's Food and Water Squeeze2020 | Water and Food
- Why the world's water demand looked set to outrun supply by 20502020 | Water and Food
More from earlier editions
- Earlier analysis sorted by topic Regions
- Indonesia's food strategy and its water security future Water and Food