Key points
- Two supermarket chains held well over two-thirds of Australian grocery sales by 2014.
- Shoppers gained cheaper food, but many farmers and small suppliers faced thinner margins and tougher terms.
- Discount milk, store brands and strict produce specifications all shifted costs back up the chain.
- Stronger codes, regular review of competition law and support for grower groups were put forward as remedies.
Background
By mid-2014, grocery retailing in Australia was concentrated to an unusual degree. Two national chains, both parts of large diversified conglomerates, together controlled more than 70 per cent of supermarket sales, roughly double their combined share four decades earlier. A discount chain held around a tenth of the market, and the rest was spread across thousands of smaller grocers.
That scale brought real gains for households. Prices on many lines fell over the preceding three years, the two chains employed close to 300,000 people, and their reach gave farmers access to buyers right across the country. Food in Australia was among the most affordable in the world as a share of household income.
Where the pressure fell
The other side of the ledger sat with suppliers. With fewer retail outlets to sell through, growers and processors had little room to bargain over price, volume or contract terms. Several practices drew criticism at the time:
- Discount milk. In 2011 both chains cut store-brand milk to a dollar a litre. Farmers reportedly received well under the cost of production for much of that period, and dozens of dairy farms were sold.
- Marketing levies. Vegetable growers were asked to pay extra per crate to join a celebrity-fronted promotion, on top of existing marketing charges, and many felt unable to refuse.
- Store brands. House-label lines took prime shelf space, narrowing the range on offer and making it harder for small brands to be stocked.
- Produce specifications. Rules on size, shape, colour, packaging and farming method added costs for smaller growers and pushed rejected produce into waste.
Because the chains earned income across hardware, liquor, fuel and other businesses, they could absorb grocery price wars in a way that smaller rivals could not. In many country towns the result was fewer local shops and less choice for residents.
Risks to the wider food system
The longer-term worry was consolidation further back in the chain. Suppliers facing steady price pressure tend either to cut costs or to grow larger, and the latter pointed toward fewer, bigger farms, often growing a single crop. A narrower base of producers is more exposed to pests, disease, drought and a warming climate. Distribution through a handful of large city warehouses added another point of fragility, while thin storage in remote areas left some regional and Indigenous communities with poor access to fresh food.
Proposed responses
The national competition regulator had launched an inquiry into supplier treatment in 2013, but its record in proving unconscionable conduct was patchy and penalties were small. Ideas canvassed in 2014 included a voluntary grocery code with real sanctions and limits on below-cost promotions, regular review of competition law, regional branding schemes funded partly by government, and a revival of farmer co-operatives, whose numbers had fallen sharply over twenty years. Shoppers willing to pay a little more at farmers' markets or smaller grocers were also seen as part of the answer. The aim was balance: enough seller power to keep diverse producers in business, without pushing retail prices above competitive levels.
Why it matters for Australia
Retail concentration bore directly on the incomes of Australian farmers and on how resilient the national food supply was to shocks. The debate in 2014 fed into later work on grocery codes and agricultural competitiveness policy.
First published in 2014 and rewritten for this edition. It describes events as they stood at the time and is general information only, not advice.
Related from earlier editions
- Why Beijing Chose Barley, Wine and Beef: Reading the 2020 Trade Barriers2020 | Regions
- Growing Food Where People Live: The Case for City Farming in Australia2015 | Regions
- Restoring the north and inland: a 2013 concept for regenerating rangelands2013 | Regions
More from earlier editions
- Earlier analysis sorted by topic Regions
- How much food Australia wastes Water and Food